Guide 04 · About 7 minutes
Ways to digitize vinyl: computer, phone, recorder or a service
There are four ways to turn records into files, and they trade money, time and quality differently. Here they are side by side, including where a phone app isn’t the right answer.
The short answer. A few precious records and no wish to do it yourself: a service. A whole collection, and you want lossless files split into tagged tracks: do it yourself, on a computer if you already sit at one, on a phone if you’d rather keep the turntable and the files in one place. A recording turntable is the quickest way to an MP3, and the least control over it.
Side by side
| Computer | Phone app | Recording turntable | Transfer service | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Software cost | Free (Audacity) or about $30–50 (VinylStudio) | Free to try, about $15 once (StylusLog) | Built in | Per record, often around $10–35, plus shipping |
| Gear you need | A USB turntable, or a turntable and a USB phono preamp | The same, plus a cable to the phone | The recording turntable | None; you post the records |
| Your time per LP | Two sides in real time, plus editing | Two sides in real time; splitting is mostly automatic | Two sides in real time | Packing and waiting |
| Split into tracks | By hand (Audacity) or helped by a track listing (VinylStudio) | Automatic, from the gaps and Discogs track times; you check the cuts | Usually one file per side | Depends on the service; some deliver one file per side |
| Tags and cover | Typed in (Audacity) or looked up (VinylStudio) | From Discogs | Usually none | Depends on the service |
| Lossless files | Yes (FLAC, WAV) | Yes (FLAC, WAV) | Usually MP3 | Depends on the service; some deliver MP3 only |
| Cleanup | The most tools | Declick, hum and rumble filters | None | Depends on the service |
On a computer
The classic way, and still the most flexible. The turntable’s USB cable (or a USB phono preamp’s) goes into the computer, and recording software captures each side.
- Audacity is free, on Windows, Mac and Linux. It records anything, and you do the rest by hand: place a label at each gap (its Label Sounds tool can find the quiet ones), type the titles, export the tracks. Powerful, and slow for a whole collection.
- VinylStudio is made for records and tapes, on Windows and Mac, with a free trial; it costs $29.95 or $49.95. It helps split sides from a looked-up track listing, removes clicks, and exports tagged files.
Choose it if the turntable already sits next to a computer, or you want the deepest editing: equalising, normalising, burning CDs.
On a phone
The same digital stream over USB, recorded by the phone instead. It needs a turntable or preamp with USB (a phone has no line input, and its microphone records the room), and a cable to the phone.
StylusLog, the app this site is for, records each side, finds the needle drop and the end of the side, splits it from the gaps with the Discogs track times as a guide, tags it from Discogs, and writes FLAC, WAV or M4A. It measures each side too: clicks, surface noise, hum, level. It runs on Android and iPhone; your first three albums are free, and a one-time Pro unlock covers the rest.
Choose it if you’d rather not carry records to a desk, want the splitting and tagging done for you, or don’t have a computer near the turntable. Not the best fit for detailed restoration work or burning CDs: that’s computer territory.
Step by step: on Android or on an iPhone.
With a recording turntable
Some record players record straight to a USB stick or an SD card: press record, play the side, take the stick out. No computer, no app.
The catch is control. Most save an MP3 of the whole side, at whatever level the player sets, with no track splits, no names and no cleanup. Their built-in cartridges are usually basic, and every tick and rumble goes into the file. Fine for a quick copy of a record you’ll listen to in the car; less so for an archive.
With a transfer service
You post the records, a company digitizes them and sends files back. Nothing to buy and nothing to learn, which makes sense for a handful of irreplaceable records, or when there’s no turntable at all.
Services usually charge per record, often around $10–35, plus shipping. Before you send anything, check what comes back: the file format (MP3 or lossless FLAC/WAV), whether each side is split into named tracks, and whether clicks are cleaned. Some deliver one MP3 per side; others offer lossless, split tracks for more. Over a whole collection, per-record prices add up fast, and the records travel twice.
What every way has in common
- It plays in real time. A side takes as long to record as it does to play; nothing rips a record faster.
- The source sets the ceiling. A clean record, a good stylus and a connected ground wire matter more than the software. Clean the record and the stylus first.
- A turntable needs a phono stage. Built into a USB turntable, or a USB phono preamp in between; without one, the recording is quiet and thin. See USB turntable, phono preamp or mixer?
- Keep a lossless master. FLAC or WAV first; you can always make an MP3 from it, never the other way round.
Try the phone way on your own records
StylusLog is free to try on your first three albums. Plug your gear in first: it shows whether it connects before you pay anything.
