Guide 06 · About 7 minutes
Vinyl to FLAC: the settings that matter
Lossless or not, 16 or 24-bit, which sample rate, how much space, and the tags. What each setting changes when the source is a record, and what to pick if you just want a good archive.
The short answer. Record at the rate and bit depth your USB turntable or preamp delivers, without converting. Keep FLAC as the master, tagged and with the cover inside. Make MP3 or AAC copies from it only where space matters. The cleanliness of the record and the level you record at matter far more than any of these numbers.
Why lossless
A recording of a side is the most work you’ll put into a record: cleaning it, setting the level, playing it through in real time. Keep everything you captured.
| Format | What it is | Keep it for |
|---|---|---|
| FLAC | Lossless and compressed: the same audio as the WAV, in roughly 60–80% of the space for vinyl, with tags and the cover inside | The archive |
| WAV | Uncompressed; tags are poorly supported | Editing software, DJ software, CD burning |
| MP3, AAC (M4A) | Lossy: smaller, with detail thrown away for good | Listening where space matters, made from the FLAC |
FLAC decodes back to exactly the samples that went in, so nothing is lost by choosing it over WAV. And a lossy copy can always be made later from a lossless one; never the other way round.
FLAC compression levels (0 to 8 in most encoders) change only the file size and how long encoding takes. Every level decodes to identical audio.
16 or 24-bit
Bit depth sets how far below full scale the recording can go before its own quantisation noise shows: about 96 dB for 16-bit, far more for 24-bit. A record’s own noise floor, the surface noise of the groove, sits much higher than either, typically 60 to 70 dB below the loudest music on a good pressing.
- 16-bit is enough for the music. It already resolves more than the groove carries.
- 24-bit is forgiving while recording. With peaks around −6 dBFS, as you should leave them, you give up a little of 16-bit’s range; 24-bit has so much that it doesn’t matter, and a quiet classical side recorded low loses nothing.
- Don’t convert what the device sends. If the USB turntable delivers 16-bit, recording it as 24-bit adds zeros, not detail.
StylusLog keeps 16-bit sources at 16-bit and writes anything deeper as 24-bit. On iPhone, iOS hands apps the audio at a higher resolution, so recordings there are 24-bit.
44.1, 48 or 96 kHz
The sample rate sets the highest frequency a file can hold: just under half the rate, so about 22 kHz at 44.1 kHz, which already covers the range of human hearing.
- Most USB turntables deliver 44.1 or 48 kHz, and that’s the rate to record at.
- 96 kHz (offered by some phono preamps and interfaces) keeps what the cartridge picks up above 22 kHz. Whether that’s audible is argued about; the files are about twice the size of 48 kHz.
- Avoid resampling. Recording at the device’s own rate and keeping it all the way to the file means nothing is converted on the way.
How big the files get
Uncompressed stereo audio takes a fixed amount of space per minute; FLAC then saves a share of that, less for vinyl than for a CD, because surface noise doesn’t compress well. Roughly, for a 40-minute LP:
| Setting | WAV, per minute | WAV, one LP | FLAC, one LP (roughly) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16-bit, 44.1 kHz | 10.6 MB | 420 MB | 250–300 MB |
| 24-bit, 48 kHz | 17.3 MB | 690 MB | 450–550 MB |
| 24-bit, 96 kHz | 34.6 MB | 1.4 GB | 0.9–1.1 GB |
| AAC, 256 kbps | 1.9 MB | 75 MB | (lossy) |
A hundred albums at 16-bit/44.1 kHz FLAC fit in about 30 GB; at 24-bit/96 kHz, about 100 GB. Plan the archive’s home (a computer, a drive, cloud storage) before the phone fills up.
Tags and cover art
FLAC carries its tags inside the file (as Vorbis comments) and the cover as an embedded picture, so an album moved to another device or player arrives named, numbered and with its sleeve. Worth having in every track:
- Title, artist, album artist, album, year: what every player sorts by. Album artist keeps a compilation or a guest spot in one album.
- Track number and total: so the sides play in order.
- Label and catalogue number: which pressing this is, which matters when there are several.
- The cover, embedded, a few hundred pixels or more.
StylusLog fills these from the release you pick on Discogs, adds the Discogs release ID and track position, and
embeds the cover; it names the files by position and title, like A1 Low Tide.flac, in a folder
named Artist - Album (Year).
Copies for listening
FLAC plays in most music apps on Android, in the Files app on an iPhone, and in most players on a computer. Apple Music on a Mac doesn’t import FLAC; for it, convert to Apple Lossless (ALAC), which is lossless too.
For a phone short on space, an AAC copy at 256 kbps sounds very close to the original for most listening, at about a quarter of a 16-bit FLAC’s size, and less still next to a 24-bit one. StylusLog exports this as M4A. Make it from the FLAC, keep the FLAC.
To record the side in the first place: on Android or on an iPhone; and to split it into tracks, splitting a vinyl recording.
Tagged FLAC from your own records
StylusLog is free to try on your first three albums, FLAC included. Plug your gear in first: it shows whether it connects before you pay anything.
